Need a Fresh Start for Your Internet Business? Grab My FREE Report!

What Voting System Should I Use for Our Best WordPress Design Contest?

Keller Hawthorne | August 28, 2009 | 19 Comments
Best WP Design Contest
What Voting System Should I Use for Our Best WordPress Design Contest?

When I first launched our Best WordPress Design Contest, I spent hours researching different voting systems.

I considered using #Hashtags on Twitter, embedding Tweetizen, using external contest platforms, etc.

I found a ton of cool blog services, but none of them were right for this contest.

My Voting System Requirements:

  • Each person can only vote once per design.
  • Voting needs to be easy so nominees can capture as many votes as possible.
  • I need to be able to rely on the data.

I thought I had this figured out – I was going to use my WP-Polls plugin as the voting system for our contest. It’s quick, easy, and to the point.

WP-Poll Voting System

With this system, people can easily find their favorite (nominees will be listed in alphabetical order) and click through to each website. Sweet and simple, right?

PROS:

  • I can prevent people from voting more than once.
  • I can allow everyone to vote for several favorites or just one favorite.
  • I can get great result data.
  • It’s super simple and easy to use.
  • Each nominee’s name will be linked to their website.

CONS:

  • I can’t add thumbnails of each design.
  • People can’t leave comments for specific nominees.

EXAMPLE:

Best WordPress Design of 2009

Loading ... Loading ...

Cheddr Media Voting System

Today, I stumbled on a very slick contest widget from Cheddr Media. I can actually embed this contest system onto my blog as you can see below.

PROS

  • I can prevent people from voting more than once per nominee.
  • I can add thumbnails of each nominee’s design.
  • Voters can leave comments on each individual nominee’s entry.
  • Each nominee’s name will be linked to their website.
  • I can add it to both my sidebar and voting page.

CONS

  • Voters will have to scroll down (and possible WAY down) the page to get to their favorite.

NOT SURE IF PRO OR CON

  • I can’t prevent people from voting for multiple nominees (voting for Nominee A AND Nominee B).
  • All votes are visible to everyone.
  • Voters can view nominees by recent entries (this will be alphabetical), top voted or random.

EXAMPLE:

Which Do You Prefer?

So, I need your help – afterall, this is about YOUR blog. Which system do you prefer? Please use the two examples above to VOTE for your preferred voting system. This way, you can see exactly how each works and get a feel for which one works best.

Leave a Vote on the WP-Poll Example to Vote for It.

Leave a Vote on the Cheddr Media Example to Vote for It.

WP Greet Box icon
Never miss a post - Subscribe To My RSS Feed and receive updates on new posts related to growing your Internet business!

Topic Tags:

, , ,

  • http://www.matthaltom.com/ Matt Haltom

    The Cheddr Media Voting System seems like the best, especially since the name can be linked to the website, making it easy to view other nominees.

  • http://zebida.com/main/ Hesham

    Entries “ON”.. Entries “OFF” and you have the best looking Poll!

    This is a good find Keller, I got my account on Cheddr now and I am discovering it, it looks great and also has a widget that all nominees can add to their blogs, so the vote can be done anywhere (but maybe this option will make you lose traffic!)

    I agree that the long screen is another problem, when setting the thumbs of nominees, you can not set the size of the main frame because it has a fixed size, wich will make it so long way to get there!

    Some good and some bad!! I am not sure yet what to pick, but I will make a my mind latter after thinking more about it! Thanks Keller for the great useful post!

  • http://blog.cult-of-pop.com/ jonathan

    yeah- Cheddr looks the best- looks are all important when it comes to design- same should go for the voting system me thinks!!

  • kimdoyal

    Hi Keller,
    Tough decision…..don't know how objective my choice is as I tend to go for visual most of the time…
    So, think I'd have to go with Cheddr (so I'll go vote after I post this!).
    REALLY like the new blog design too!
    Kim

  • beverlyhillsfarmgrl

    Oops – I accidentally voted for the WP-Poll system but I think I prefer Cheddr for its visuals. Whatever your readers wish works for me – I am just honored to be in the running. Thank you for organizing this fun event and good luck to all contestants!

  • http://zebida.com/main/ Hesham

    It seem that everybody will go for the nice looking poll!

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    Be sure to keep me informed of your decision Hesham – since we'll both be launching our contests this week, we can definitely help each other out!

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    Thank you Kim!

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    Thanks so much for entering the contest Dana!

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    Ok, so far we have 7 votes for the WP-Poll voting system and 10 for Cheddr.

  • http://whatawebsite.org/ whatawebsite

    Hi Keller, Cheddr gets my vote, Best wishes Will

  • http://zebida.com/main/ Hesham

    Sure!

  • http://www.nazcarpine.com nazcar

    Hi Keller, I go for the Cheddr Media.
    Regards

  • http://www.facebook.com/sherri.joubert Sherri Joubert

    I voted for WP poll, but I do like the Cheddr format, being able to see thumbnails. What I don't like about Cheddr is you can vote for multiple entries.

    Can you limit the number of entries anyone can vote for to some number other than 1 per poll, like you can vote once for 5 entries and it will stop you after that? That would be good and I would lke that b/c some designs will be fantastic for different reasons than others. It might be good to pick more than one, but not be able to pick all entries.

    Thumbnails are important. This is a design contest so the visual is important.

    Are there enough entries to allow voting for more than one blog?

    How's that for being wishee-washee???

    Sherri

  • http://www.seomkt.com/ bbrian017

    Keller, you might be interested in using a service from a members of ours over at blogengage. His name is AssWass and can be found here, http://www.hiburrito.com Sign up and see if it's something you can use.

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    Thanks for the tip Brian! I checked it out, but decided to just customize my WP-Polls plugin. It seemed to be the easiest way to do this.

  • http://www.seomkt.com/ bbrian017

    What you did also looked good. AssWass works hard at his websites I promised I would mention it :)

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    I'm glad you did as I was getting concerned about the system, but WP-Polls seems to have worked out well.

  • http://www.fresheventure.com Keller Hawthorne

    I'm glad you did as I was getting concerned about the system, but WP-Polls seems to have worked out well.

TOP SECRET MOBILE MONEY TECHNOLOGY

Copyright © 2011 · FresheVenture.com · All Rights Reserved · StudioPress Lifestyle Theme Customized by KBH Web Marketing · Terms of Service · Privacy Policy · Site Map