Following Google Guidelines: Buying and Selling Links and PageRank
This week, I had to turn down another advertising opportunity. I get approached often with requests to purchase text links on my blog. I’m always open to these opportunities as long as they follow Google’s Guidelines. Unfortunately, they never do.
Is the Buying or Selling of Links Against Google Guidelines?
Absolutely not! Buy and sell away. Your website is YOUR online real estate and you get to choose what goes on it. It’s paid advertising and it’s perfectly legal (even in Google’s eyes). So, why am I turning these offers down?
Is the Buying or Selling of Links That Pass Along PageRank Against Google Guidelines?
YES! Paid links (be it banner ads or text links) that pass along PageRank ARE AGAINST Google Guidelines and can potentially get you banned from the search engine. Paid links that pass PR are considered a form of SEO or PageRank manipulation.
You may notice you get more requests for text link ads when your PR is high versus when it’s low. That’s because those advertisers aren’t offering to pay you for your ad space, but rather for your PageRank!
How Does a Link Pass Or Not Pass PageRank?
A link passes PR when it’s considered a “Do-Follow” link. The ONLY time a link is NOT considered Do-Follow is when it’s assigned the “No-Follow” attribute like this:
OR when a Meta tag is placed at the top of a web page applying No-Follow to all links.
The Power of a Text Link
Some people get confused about this “Paid Link Google Guideline” and begin to believe text links are bad. They’re not – they just happen to be the more common type of advertising webmasters offer to pay for when trying to gain PR. So, why are text links more valuable than banner ads?
A text link offers a webmaster the ability to add valuable keywords as the text of the link. These keywords are what tell search engines what the destination site is about.
So, when you link to a site with the keyword term “Home Decor,” Google believes that’s what the site is about. This helps that destination site prove its relevance to that keyword term. And that’s what search rankings are all about, right?
The site that has proven it is the most relevant to the term “Home Decor” gets to hold the number one position on the first page of results for that search term.
A banner ad, on the other hand, only offers an Alt Tag for SEO – no text.
Who Buys Text and Who Buys Banners?
It is my experience that people who buy text links are often after PageRank while people who buy banners are after traffic. However, even No-Follow (won’t pass PR) text links can generate traffic for advertisers as they have the awesome ability to not appear to be ads.
Do-Follow Paid Links Manipulate Search Engines
If you think about it, the activity of buying Do-Follow links really is a shortcut to building a valuable website. Rather than building quality content that naturally earns inbound links, advertisers attempt to purchase the benefits of SEO. It’s FAKE and I’m not surprised Google bans this behavior.
If I were to accept one of these deals and link to a website, it would be purely for profit. Now, that’s exactly what I do with my banner ad spots, so don’t get me wrong – of course I’m trying to earn money. But all of my banner ad spots are No-Follow. I’m not telling Google, “Hey, I happen to think this site is relevant to ‘Blah Blah’. In fact, I think it’s so relevant and high quality, I want to pass along my PageRank to it.” Do you see the difference?
Of course selling ad space is about earning a buck. But it shouldn’t be about manipulating search engines. That’s how CRAP sites gain high rankings. That’s how search engines become useless. That’s how the good sites get hurt and the bad sites get traffic.
Your PageRank Has Value – Take Care of It
Your PR plays a role in your search engine rankings and can even change the way other webmasters view your website. A site with high PR is usually considered more valuable and powerful than one with little or no PR. Your PR can dramatically increase the number of sites that talk about you, link to you, connect with you and request link exchanges from you.
With such “power” comes responsibility. IT MATTERS who you link to. Google cares about the type of websites you connect with. If you decide to link to a bad seed, your site could be harmed.
Just as having high PR can dramatically help a website, having your PR removed can drastically harm a website.
My Own Experience
Due to what appears to have been a glitch in the system, I lost my PR for over a month this year and trust me – it hurt. It never impacted my traffic or rankings (like I said, I believe it was a glitch), but it did alter the way other people viewed my site.
My PR wasn’t just removed – I was gray barred. Now, when you’re gray barred, it either means your site hasn’t been indexed in Google yet (your site is new) OR your site is considered NAUGHTY.
Advertisers stopped knocking on my door and a couple people left nasty comments about it on my posts. Who wants to mingle with a naughty website, right? Fortunately, with the next PR update, my PageRank reappeared, but the impact of this experience has stuck with me.
The Website That Cried Wolf
That PR issue brought up a great point that I had never thought of before. Once I was at my wits end, I decided to join the Google Webmaster Forum and ask for help on the issue. Immediately, the power users began dissecting my blog, looking for ANY way I may have been breaking Google’s rules. Fortunately, I knew that I had not knowingly done anything wrong, which helped me to obtain more help rather than finger pointing in the end.
I was able to obtain quality help from webmasters because I was able to prove I was a “good girl.” Now imagine if I had been selling Do-Follow links. Do you think I would have received much help or support if I knowingly broke Google’s rules?
It Still Sucks!
Excuse my language, but yes – following the rules isn’t always fun. I’ve lost out on some pretty good revenue opportunities just to please Google. So, why do I bother? After all it is MY website and I have EVERY RIGHT to put WHATEVER I want on it!
I guess it comes down to what is more valuable to you. Would you rather receive a thousand dollars a year placing Do-Follow links on your website? Or, would you prefer to obtain high Google search engine rankings that lead to lots of traffic that can be converted into a long-term revenue source? The paid link opportunities will fade away, but your PR and rankings (or lack thereof) can last for years. So, what is more important to you?